Best Australian Nintendo Wii Community, News, Games, Videos, Competitions, and Forums. Mario Galaxy, Metroid and More!

Polls \ What makes a good game?

3 3%
Graphics!
 
61 62%
Gameplay, of course
 
9 9%
Creativity
 
6 6%
Replay value
 
2 2%
Originality
 
1 1%
Sound!
 
1 1%
Controls
 
10 10%
Storyline
 
4 4%
multiplayer
 
Total: 97 Votes

Comments

ragin_bull
Kudos: 1,809
Mates: 1
ragin_bull says:  

wii4life said: Koogan said: wii4life said:

Koogan said: Who the hell picked graphics

ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love to have graphics

Right so umm...if a game had practically real-life graphics...but yuo can't do anything on it...yeh

Pretty much i rather graphics's maybe a little bit of a good story line



Yeh man real life graphics for sure.... I can't be stuffed going outside, or even looking outside.

I remember people were complaining that Metroid Prime didn't look "realistic" enough. I totally agree. Those space pirates and metroids look nothing like what they do in real life.... And those plasma beams? Psh, they obviously have no clue.

Seriously why play games then. If your into something looking nice with a bit of a storyline, buy a Blue Ray DVD and a player.
17/03/2008
Resident Evil 4
Gullible isn't a real word.
wii4life
Kudos: 4,209
Mates: 91
wii4life says:  

Koogan said: wii4life said:

Koogan said: Who the hell picked graphics

ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love to have graphics

Right so umm...if a game had practically real-life graphics...but yuo can't do anything on it...yeh


Pretty much i rather graphics's maybe a little bit of a good story line
17/03/2008
Ninja Reflex
Brisbane
Version2
Kudos: 6,756
Mates: 125
Version2 says:  
Gameplay makes a good game, but the rest added to it make a great game! if gameplay is bad, chances are I won't play it.
17/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Reality is just a virtual concept
syfox133
Kudos: 8,105
Mates: 144
syfox133 says:  

nonsimia47 said: they're all crutial, if one sux, they all sux

BING BING BING. We have a weiner.
17/03/2008
Metal Slug Anthology
In the corner of your eye
nonsimia47
Kudos: 943
Mates: 34
nonsimia47 says:  
they're all crutial, if one sux, they all sux
17/03/2008
House of the Dead 2 & 3 Return
USA
DonRicho
Kudos: 666
Mates: 23
DonRicho says:  
must...fight urge...to kill...graphics whores
but seriously graphics are important but theyre a secondary feature, if theyre that important then go watch movie
16/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Stirling, South Australia
jackoltene
Kudos: 13,461
Mates: 1533
jackoltene says:  
gameplay and probably replay value you dont spend 100 bucks to just finish a game in a week or 2
16/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
sydney
Omi
Kudos: 7,411
Mates: 155
Omi says:  

rainbow84 said: i went with majority
i was going to say creativity, though

That doesn't make any sense! If everyone went with the majority, it wouldn't be the majority, it would just be an image of what the first people thought!

You won't get very far in life with that attitude! Don't be afraid to be yourself, who else is going to step up and be you?


Creativity for me, without that, the rest is nothing.
16/03/2008
Mario Kart Wii
In the vegie patch
meef
Kudos: 510
Mates: 69
meef says:  
gameplay gameplay gameplay! i mean yes a good story, graphics and controls can improve a game, but definately not make a game. if its got crap gameplay youre never going to play it. also replay value falls under gameplay too cause if its got good gameplay of course youre going to play it again... and anyone that said graphics is a tool.
16/03/2008
Mario Kart Wii
Launceston, Tasmania
BlakKnight
Kudos: 4,226
Mates: 93
BlakKnight says:  
Storyline is the best!
graphics are good but what if the game is Staring Contest EXTREME!
they dont help much there
16/03/2008
Super Paper Mario
YOU DARE BRING LIGHT INTO MY LAIR!? YOU MUST DIE!!!
Koogan
Kudos: 2,515
Mates: 109
Koogan says:  

wii4life said:
Koogan said: Who the hell picked graphics
ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love to have graphics


Right so umm...if a game had practically real-life graphics...but yuo can't do anything on it...yeh
16/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
A house :P
Ferenc
Kudos: 1,135
Mates: 35
Ferenc says:  

Orion said: controls, to me controls are the main part of any game. That's why I own a wii, thats why I play COD4 on computer instead of buying an Xbox, because dualstick sucks. MOH:H2 had excellent controls, mostly all RTS and FPS games on computer have good controls all Nintendo games have good controls. Controls make my game!



Orion said: That's why I own a wii,


that's the only problem with what you just said.
like 99.9 percent of wii game's controls are crap
infact just about every non-nintendo wii game and that DK barrel racing game have controls that are soo horid they make me want to hang myself with the nunchuck

but yeah gameplay always makes a good game
but good controls are needed for good gameplay

oh yeah I laugh at whoever said graphics
16/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Newfoundland, Canada
RenegadeKL
Kudos: 601
Mates: 72
RenegadeKL says:  
In all the years that ive played games ive got to admit that gameplay plays the more important role then the rest just fall into place such as
controls, sound, storyline and multiplayer is a bonus!
16/03/2008
Melbourne Victoria
Orion
Kudos: 1,028
Mates: 30
Orion says:  
controls, to me controls are the main part of any game. That's why I own a wii, thats why I play COD4 on computer instead of buying an Xbox, because dualstick sucks. MOH:H2 had excellent controls, mostly all RTS and FPS games on computer have good controls all Nintendo games have good controls. Controls make my game!
15/03/2008
Sydney NSW
codyt
Kudos: 779
Mates: 33
codyt says:  
creativity, the most enjoyable games are creative and different from most, so thats by far the most important for me.
15/03/2008
Dr. Mario & Germ Buster
melbourne
Cascada97
Kudos: 4,397
Mates: 274
Cascada97 says:  
who would vote sound? wth?
15/03/2008
Mario Kart Wii
*sings* somewhere over the rainbow... well, sydney
ragin_bull
Kudos: 1,809
Mates: 1
ragin_bull says:  
No T and A option?

DOA volleyball and Rumble Roses are awesome games!
15/03/2008
Resident Evil 4
Gullible isn't a real word.
cmpa1970
Kudos: 9,119
Mates: 2380
cmpa1970 says:  
gameplay.......
15/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Sydney, NSW
wii4life
Kudos: 4,209
Mates: 91
wii4life says:  

Koogan said: Who the hell picked graphics



ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love to have graphics
15/03/2008
Ninja Reflex
Brisbane
Koogan
Kudos: 2,515
Mates: 109
Koogan says:  
Who the hell picked graphics
15/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
A house :P
rainbow84
Kudos: 474
Mates: 40
rainbow84 says:  
i went with majority

i was going to say creativity, though
15/03/2008
Super Mario Galaxy
cairns, QLD
m24ychal
Kudos: 1,999
Mates: 247
m24ychal says:  
a mutiplayer storyline with goodgameplay would be awesome!
15/03/2008
Mario Super Sluggers
Why so serious???
Harlster
Kudos: 8,679
Mates: 53
Harlster says:  
Gameplay. Though creativity and originality are extremely important I think that a game's gameplay matters more.
15/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Melbourne [city of stuff, wooo!]
Silence
Kudos: 5,814
Mates: 77
Silence says:  
I voted Re-Playability as a look for that just a hint more than gameplay. You forgot multiplayer!
15/03/2008
Bully: Scholarship Edition
Want something for nothing? Of course you do! https://mywii.com.au/Post.aspx?id=10311&p=1 Kingsbury, Victoria
gdmatt
Kudos: 2,130
Mates: 264
gdmatt says:  
Gameplay, of course.
Also Originality and Replay Value
15/03/2008
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
Melbourne, Victoria
brawl4all
Kudos: 3,197
Mates: 170
brawl4all says:  
this poll will be ALMOST as one-sided as the wifi night decision
15/03/2008
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, The
Animal Crossing
ICC_06
Kudos: 13,379
Mates: 488
ICC_06 says:  
Gameplay if the game is not good and enjoyable they why would I be playing it?
15/03/2008
The Conduit
Why was the juice factory worker fired? He couldn't concentrate
Robtot
Kudos: 7,068
Mates: 131
Robtot says:  
I voted creativity, I'm more interested in seeing creative new ways of doing things in games. For me I still enjoy games if they have bugs or gameplay issues if they're creative, like No More Heroes or Path of Neo, both buggy, both not the best game play ever, but very creative. I want more people taking chances in the industry

15/03/2008
Wii Fit
Gae: When did Reggie become awesome? Robtot: When he kicked your ass and took your name :O
KonkyDong
Kudos: 3,234
Mates: 208
KonkyDong says:  

damex95 said: Gameplay!

...Of course...



amen to that!
15/03/2008
Guitar Hero III
waiting, watching..........................learning
damex95
Kudos: 3,669
Mates: 660
damex95 says:  
Gameplay!
...Of course...
15/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Sydney
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyWii Says:

Polls

Do You Think Wii MotionPlus and 1:1 Controls Have Any Merit? 84

Games

  • The Conduit
  • MySims Party
  • Wii Play
  • Alvin and the Chipmunks: Rockathonapalooza

News

Cammie Dunaway Talks E3 Disappointment, Miyamoto and More
1 days ago 30 14 430
eGames 2008, Meet iDEF!
1 days ago 27 10 280
I Am Alive To Take A More Realistic Approach
2 days ago 16 12 440
Nintendo leads as US console sales slump
3 days ago 24 26 600
Disaster: Day of Crisis Rated by the OFLC
4 days ago 21 11 420

Videos

  • Destroy all Humans BWU - Intro and gameplay
    Destroy all Humans BWU - Intro and gameplay
  • Latest Trailer for LEGO Batman: The Videogame
    Latest Trailer for LEGO Batman: The Videogame
  • Wii Ad
    Wii Ad
  • Real Life Donkey Kong
    Real Life Donkey Kong

Best Photos

  • The Geekini
    25 28
  • Show us your B00B5!
    43 26
  • MyWii Member Wall, Wiidude007!
    43 22
  • LOL!
    29 20
  • The Search for the lost kids.
    19 18
  • squirril marine
    6 17

Blogs

Comic Delay II: The Wrath Of Khan
6 hours ago 22 17
MyBluRay Movie Trivia III: The Return of Medals (Win a Blu-Ray disc of your choice!)
2 days ago 21 0
Comic #2.09 - 'Nerd Rage'
6 days ago 30 38
Things to do to prepare your self for Street fighter 4
13/08/2008 46 8
Comics: A slight delay...
13/08/2008 41 40

Comments

Resident Evil 4 - Wii Edition Trailer. j_One1986 12 mins ago
MadWorld and House of Dead: Overkill Banned In A Country Already dcel8 14 mins ago
Share 2008 Olympic Games video boxhunter 30 mins ago
Wii Rifle Bennster 1 hours ago
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker insidious 1 hours ago
Guitar Hero: World Tour - more tracks turkey682 1 hours ago
Primary Wii player is under 25, male…secondary Wii player is under 25, male/female split nearly sjt333 1 hours ago
MadWorld and House of Dead: Overkill Banned In A Country Already jackoltene 2 hours ago
Primary Wii player is under 25, male…secondary Wii player is under 25, male/female split nearly TGCMandCo 2 hours ago
MadWorld and House of Dead: Overkill Banned In A Country Already jofra01 2 hours ago

Everyone is...

Bennster: a bright and hard working individual, offering help if needed at any time.
loving mywii.com and all its members, you guys have been great.
if help is needed dont be afraid to ask ;)
b3nnii: he he, my pic is now the most popular. :P
Bennster: a bright and hard working individual, offering help if needed at any time.
loving mywii.com and all its members, you guys have been great.
if help is needed dont be afraid to ask ;)
DjChopper: Got the homebrew channel up and running XD
Wii_Man876: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnNTggdboEM&feature=rec-fresh

Cant stop listening to it!
Invite your friends!
Send us news tips!