Best Australian Nintendo Wii Community, News, Games, Videos, Competitions, and Forums. Mario Galaxy, Metroid and More!

Wii Hardware \ Possible Classic and GameCube Controller Ban?

jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97
After losing a bid to overturn a US$21 million patent-infringement verdict against Anascape Ltd., Nintendo is facing a ban on sales of the Wii Classic Controller and standard and Wavebird versions of the GameCube controller in the US, it's been reported.

The ban is scheduled to be issued today by US District Judge Ron Clark in Lufkin, Texas, and Nintendo will have to post a bond or put royalties in an escrow account to avoid it.

Nintendo spokesman Charlie Scibetta said "Nintendo was already planning to appeal this case to the Federal Circuit court," and that "The recent ruling by the trial court does not impact that decision."

Once Anascape's order has been submitted, Nintendo will "immediately appeal" and post a bond said Scibetta. He said that Nintendo no longer makes the GameCube controllers, and "is free to continue selling the Wii Classic Controller" pending the appeal.

Fortunately for Nintendo, jurors agreed that its Wii Remote and Nunchuk controllers don't violate the patent at the heart of the case - owned by inventor Brad Armstrong - which covers certain configuration to control six types of motions at the same time.

Continued Next Post
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

Anascape's lawyer argued that the company was entitled to a ban on the Nintendo controllers because it wants to enter the market and Nintendo has "clogged the channel." Sony diced with Anascape in 2004, licensing its patent, and Microsoft settled lawsuit claims on May 1 prior to the trial's commencement.

Nintendo's stance? It said it didn't use Anascape's technology and challenged the patent's validity.

Source: www.aussie-nintendo.com/

So Nintendo probably won't be able to sell Classic Controllers and Nintendo does still make Gamecube Controllers in Japan
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
Matteh
Kudos: 4,382
Mates: 84
Well that sucks doesnt it. I better go out and buy a few classics and some mroe gamecubes before they stop making them.

GAH! People...some are just so annoying lol

=D
24/07/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Bored Much?? Yes! Very much bored! D=
sjt333
Kudos: 11,434
Mates: 135
i read about this yesterday and Anascapes law suit still sounds damn suspicious.

The patent:

A hand operated controller or converter structured for allowing hand inputs to be converted or translated into electrical outputs, the controller structured with a plate or platform moveable relative to a base or housing about two mutually perpendicular axes generally parallel to the platform to effect a plurality of sensors for defining output signal(s) based on movement of the platform. The sensors each have an electrically active activator spatially separated from an electric contact surface. A tactile feedback motor with shaft and offset weight is mounted as a component of the controller for providing vibration to be felt by a hand operating the controller. In some embodiments the sensors are pressure sensitive variable output sensors.

they obviously wanted to screw with the wiimote but why are gamecube and classic controllers the only ones targeted?
24/07/2008
Altered Beast
Burninating the countryside
malaka
Kudos: 4,596
Mates: 82
**** off! how bloody annoying is that who is this anascape anyway? sounds like they are annoying and need to be whacked
24/07/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
[Brawl F/C = 2879-0042-4817] ~ Melb, Vic
sjt333
Kudos: 11,434
Mates: 135

malaka said: **** off! how bloody annoying is that who is this anascape anyway? sounds like they are annoying and need to be whacked

noone knows kotaku did a search and couldnt find anything

But who is Texas-based Anascape? Nobody much, apparently. They seem to lack an official website, and even a WhitePages.com search reveals no such business listing in Tyler, Texas. It's an Ltd — Limited liability company — which means it could be simply an investment partnership and not a headquartered office at all.

its just weird that anascape filed against all three(sony,msoft,ninty) at once
24/07/2008
Altered Beast
Burninating the countryside
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

sjt333 said:

malaka said: **** off! how bloody annoying is that who is this anascape anyway? sounds like they are annoying and need to be whacked

noone knows kotaku did a search and couldnt find anything

But who is Texas-based Anascape? Nobody much, apparently. They seem to lack an official website, and even a WhitePages.com search reveals no such business listing in Tyler, Texas. It's an Ltd — Limited liability company — which means it could be simply an investment partnership and not a headquartered office at all.

its just weird that anascape filed against all three(sony,msoft,ninty) at once



Probably some Investment firm who has a secret brain child who patents everything, at least they didn't get the WiiMote and Nunchuk which were objectives
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
Rainbow7
Kudos: 1,432
Mates: 75
Well, they won't be getting my WaveBirds/GC Controllers back!

Quick, guys, get one of these from Play-Asia:

24/07/2008
Without ME, it's just "AWESO"...
boxhunter
Kudos: 4,818
Mates: 110
Serious they stopping selling of Classic Controller
I like them..
24/07/2008
Mario Kart Wii
Mario Kart Wi-Fi Night Edition One Champion!
kolpol9
Kudos: 10,728
Mates: 571
so why it getting banned?
24/07/2008
Josepi says: making stuff for nazis isnt what I call a good job
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

Rainbow7 said: Well, they won't be getting my WaveBirds/GC Controllers back!

Quick, guys, get one of these from Play-Asia:



already did

kolpol9 said: so why it getting banned?



this unknown company claims that they patented the analog stick thing first before Nintendo, Sony & Microsfot so they sued them all
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
Azza123
Kudos: 10,073
Mates: 183
They should learn to share and get over it. Seriously.
24/07/2008
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
''Blades Will Bleed''
kolpol9
Kudos: 10,728
Mates: 571
What about the nunchuck? and what about...

eg. the first keyboard? and the vii? and microsoft and sony copying motion sensingan they sue for that?
24/07/2008
Josepi says: making stuff for nazis isnt what I call a good job
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

kolpol9 said: What about the nunchuck? and what about...

eg. the first keyboard? and the vii? and microsoft and sony copying motion sensingan they sue for that?



It's a complete mess Microsoft and Sony I both think settled out of court, also the people suing were trying to get the Nunchuk and WiiMote banned but Nintendo are gonna put an appeal in place which means that when the things become banned they will become unbanned with Nintendo's appeal
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
sjt333
Kudos: 11,434
Mates: 135

jofra01 said:

kolpol9 said: so why it getting banned?



this unknown company claims that they patented the analog stick thing first before Nintendo, Sony & Microsfot so they sued them all

maybe atari should sue annascape since an atari console was the first console to have a analog stick
24/07/2008
Altered Beast
Burninating the countryside
grimace
Kudos: 2,333
Mates: 58
Uhhh, all these companies jumping on board to get a cut of Nintendo's profit are pretty dodgy. And that patent was so generic they could probably get a buck out of Microsoft and Sony while they're at it
24/07/2008
Zack & Wiki: Quest For Barbaros' Treasure
some random suburb in Perth, WA
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

grimace said: Uhhh, all these companies jumping on board to get a cut of Nintendo's profit are pretty dodgy. And that patent was so generic they could probably get a buck out of Microsoft and Sony while they're at it



They did
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
sjt333
Kudos: 11,434
Mates: 135
if only phoenix wright were real, nintendo would win
24/07/2008
Altered Beast
Burninating the countryside
hamzie
Kudos: 6,607
Mates: 336
So new classic controllers will be released now?
24/07/2008
Mario Kart Wii
Kaptain Kay's bed
Tsunamo
Kudos: 1,293
Mates: 71

jofra01 said:

Rainbow7 said: Well, they won't be getting my WaveBirds/GC Controllers back!

Quick, guys, get one of these from Play-Asia:



already did

kolpol9 said: so why it getting banned?



this unknown company claims that they patented the analog stick thing first before Nintendo, Sony & Microsfot so they sued them all

thats Bu** S***!!!!!!
24/07/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
W.A,Perth
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

hamzie said: So new classic controllers will be released now?



maybe the ones that Nintendo have patented like this www.mywii.com.au/ also would this stand only in America or World Wide?

24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
hamzie
Kudos: 6,607
Mates: 336
does this mean Analog controllers will be stopped or something ?

i dont get it.. how can they sue over analog stick
24/07/2008
Mario Kart Wii
Kaptain Kay's bed
jofra01
Kudos: 13,812
Mates: 97

hamzie said: does this mean Analog controllers will be stopped or something ?

i dont get it.. how can they sue over analog stick



Not really sure how it works but apparently they filed a patent that had something to do with analog sticks and the gamecube controller, Classic Controller and the Sony & Microsoft Controllers were very similar to the patent while the Nunchuk wasn't as similar which is why the Nunchuk wasn't banned.
24/07/2008
Captain Rainbow
New Members Stay Away From Matteh, Bad Influence He Is.
hamzie
Kudos: 6,607
Mates: 336
So they all have to change their controller style?

Thats silly.. should be whoever released the controller first
24/07/2008
Mario Kart Wii
Kaptain Kay's bed
Azza123
Kudos: 10,073
Mates: 183
They should share, but like usaul, it's all about the money, greedy swine.
24/07/2008
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
''Blades Will Bleed''
 
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyWii Says:

Polls

Games

  • Tony Hawk's Proving Ground
  • Godzilla : Unleashed
  • Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
  • Wii Music

News

Videos

  • Funny wii video
    Funny wii video
  • Street Fighter: The Later Years Trailer
    Street Fighter: The Later Years Trailer
  • Bullet Bill Pathing: Star Cup
    Bullet Bill Pathing: Star Cup
  • Virtual Boy Wario Land TV Commercial
    Virtual Boy Wario Land TV Commercial

Best Photos

  • Show us your B00B5!
    39 25
  • MyWii Member Wall, Wiidude007!
    43 22
  • LOL!
    23 20
  • The Search for the lost kids.
    19 18
  • The Geekini
    13 18
  • ....
    7 13

Blogs

Comments

Everyone is...

Wiioff: Going to try and get some sleep!
matty24: is sleepy but Mario begs me to stay.......
ilikeike: Confused! Jr. High is so confusing!
wiidude007: New mywii member wall in the making. PM me if you want to be in it :)
Azza123: Weasle you have never actually seen him. You have read him post. -_- Why is that so special...? Calm down and take a deep breath. >.<