Best Australian Nintendo Wii Community, News, Games, Videos, Competitions, and Forums. Mario Galaxy, Metroid and More!

News \ New Bully Controversy

The Canadian Teachers' Federation, a group representing four million teachers in several countries, is calling for the ban of Bully: Scholarship Edition. It seems as though the federation hasn’t played Bully and bases their assumptions on non-gaming public perceptions of the game.

"We're asking retailers to be responsible," said Emily Noble, president of the Canadian Teachers' Federation. "Yes, they can sell it and make a buck out of this, but is this the kind of marketing that they want to be [doing], selling games that glorify violence?"

Two major retailers in North America, PC World and Currys, have already made their stance clear on the game, refusing to stock both the 360 and Wii versions. They didn’t stock the PS2 version either.

This all comes just over a month after The Daily Telegraph in the UK called for the game to be banned.

A Rockstar spokesperson responded to the newspapers request, stating, "It is a comedic romp. The last game sold fabulously in the UK and was critically acclaimed.

"It is not a game about playing a bully. It is about the trials and tribulations of a boy in his first year at school. He protects children against other characters. People have to be able to make their own decisions and to judge for themselves, with an open mind."

Bully: Scholarship Edition is now available in Australia on the XBOX 360 and Nintendo Wii.

Submitted by Gaetano submit to digg 06/03/2008 295 17

Join MyWii to vote for your favourite story!


More Info:

Bully: Scholarship Edition

Related News:

Related Reviews:

Related Videos:

  • Bully: Scholarship Edition Trailer
    Bully: Scholarship Edition Trailer
  • Preppies - Bully
    Preppies - Bully
  • Jocks - Bully
    Jocks - Bully

Related Guides:

Comments

Stormstruk
Kudos: 3,179
Mates: 109

Diabollus said:
Well, you got different mods than I did Storm.



Yeah I also got some "adult" downloads, my word.... one of the downloads the sims couldn't leave alone!

Dirty lil buggers... anyhoo I got bored with it all after a while, you can only kill them so many different ways then it's all a bit ho hum

This Bully controversy is hilarious, can't wait to see what else happens!
09/03/2008
Wii Fit
Perth, Western Australia
sjt333
Kudos: 11,900
Mates: 137

Stormstruk said: Quick ban The Sims.

The game makes me evil because I torture my Sims and cause them to die horrific lonely deaths in the swimming pool without a ladder, in the room where the door mysteriously disappears and with those downloads I got of the "electric shower" and the "poisoned packet of chips".

BAN IT NOWWWWW



yeah you can do really really evil things in the sims and yet not one peep from people nooooooo

and yet a game were you face up to bullies theyve basically called for a public hanging of the creators
08/03/2008
Altered Beast
click the monkey
Diabollus
Kudos: 4,571
Mates: 24

Stormstruk said: Quick ban The Sims.

The game makes me evil because I torture my Sims and cause them to die horrific lonely deaths in the swimming pool without a ladder, in the room where the door mysteriously disappears and with those downloads I got of the "electric shower" and the "poisoned packet of chips".

BAN IT NOWWWWW



Well, you got different mods than I did Storm.
07/03/2008
zanthor
Kudos: 86
Mates: 4

BBking said: Is the topic of this article assumption or censorship?
Censorship: Yeah, I reckon they should sell it. Poeple can play what they want. If a kid bullies someone, then they MIGHT have this game in their bedroom. The kid who got bullied might also. There are bullies out there.
Assumption: Having not played that game I think it would be pretty gay. The facial expressions seem a bit overboard and looks, well, I have to use that word again. Gay.
Are they resposable for destroying gaming? I don't think so...



Hmmmm.
Logic analysis:
You obviously aren't impressed with the game.
The word you use to convey this is "Gay"
This implies that Gay = Bad
Me = Gay

So, by logic that means:

Me = Bad

What did I ever do to you???
07/03/2008
Melbourne, Victoria
zanthor
Kudos: 86
Mates: 4

Denor said:
jotendo said: Denor said: I think they shouldn't have made that game in the first place. It's a bad example on kids, and bullying will only increase with more things like this game happening!
you have choices in the game, to be basically good or bad in some sense.
Its not all beating up kids and being bad.
Oh, I didn't know that! Lol. Soz. My bad! But then again, we all know that most players would pick to be bad. I know I would, and that's the problem. Kids prefer to be the badguys because they like to inflict pain upon others. But anyway, I haven't done enough research into the game to criticize too much, so I'll leave it at that.



I don't think people choose to be bad in games because they want to hurt people. We play games to escape for a little while, we want to be able to be something we aren't or something we could never be, that's part of the fun of a game. You choose to make the bad choices in a game because you know it's never something you'd choose to do in real life and you'd just like to try it to see what happens in an environment without any consequences. Purely escapism.
07/03/2008
Melbourne, Victoria
Stormstruk
Kudos: 3,179
Mates: 109
Quick ban The Sims.

The game makes me evil because I torture my Sims and cause them to die horrific lonely deaths in the swimming pool without a ladder, in the room where the door mysteriously disappears and with those downloads I got of the "electric shower" and the "poisoned packet of chips".

BAN IT NOWWWWW
06/03/2008
Wii Fit
Perth, Western Australia
Denor
Kudos: 7,519
Mates: 438

jotendo said: Denor said: I think they shouldn't have made that game in the first place. It's a bad example on kids, and bullying will only increase with more things like this game happening!

you have choices in the game, to be basically good or bad in some sense.

Its not all beating up kids and being bad.



Oh, I didn't know that! Lol. Soz. My bad! But then again, we all know that most players would pick to be bad. I know I would, and that's the problem. Kids prefer to be the badguys because they like to inflict pain upon others. But anyway, I haven't done enough research into the game to criticize too much, so I'll leave it at that.
06/03/2008
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, The
I am in your fridge, eating your foodz.
syfox133
Kudos: 8,105
Mates: 144
Blame the gaming. It's self control ppl.. Canadians...eh.
06/03/2008
Metal Slug Anthology
In the corner of your eye
Orion
Kudos: 1,028
Mates: 30

sjt333 said: why cant people actually play games before they call for them to be banned



true, but I don't think we would be happy even if they did play the games and then denounced them anyway. We're a fickle community.
06/03/2008
Sydney NSW
sjt333
Kudos: 11,900
Mates: 137
why cant people actually play games before they call for them to be banned
06/03/2008
Altered Beast
click the monkey
Silence
Kudos: 5,826
Mates: 77
It's kinda like Fable in that you can chose whether you become good or bad.
06/03/2008
Bully: Scholarship Edition
Want something for nothing? Of course you do! https://mywii.com.au/Post.aspx?id=10311&p=1 Kingsbury, Victoria
jotendo
Kudos: 12,176
Mates: 263

Denor said: I think they shouldn't have made that game in the first place. It's a bad example on kids, and bullying will only increase with more things like this game happening!



you have choices in the game, to be basically good or bad in some sense.
Its not all beating up kids and being bad.
06/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Voted Sexiest Admin of 07/08
Denor
Kudos: 7,519
Mates: 438
I think they shouldn't have made that game in the first place. It's a bad example on kids, and bullying will only increase with more things like this game happening!
06/03/2008
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, The
I am in your fridge, eating your foodz.
K-Man
Kudos: 8,755
Mates: 197
Eh.... it's just Canada.
06/03/2008
Mario Kart Wii
California, U.S | MyWii, MyPS3, MyDS
Gaetano
Kudos: 501
Mates: 30

ArkiveZero said: game sucks anyway, Rockstar needs to get banned theyre the gay ass ppl that are responsible for destroying gaming



What the...?
06/03/2008
Melbourne
ICC_06
Kudos: 13,482
Mates: 489

jotendo said: QUICK buy it before it gets banned here



It will happen if anyone says anything about a game the OFLC put on their banning hat straight away.
06/03/2008
The Conduit
Why was the juice factory worker fired? He couldn't concentrate
jotendo
Kudos: 12,176
Mates: 263
QUICK buy it before it gets banned here
06/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Voted Sexiest Admin of 07/08
Silence
Kudos: 5,826
Mates: 77
Hmm, i better get myself a copy before it gets banned. Just in case.
06/03/2008
Bully: Scholarship Edition
Want something for nothing? Of course you do! https://mywii.com.au/Post.aspx?id=10311&p=1 Kingsbury, Victoria
Mario128
Kudos: 9,085
Mates: 135
Sounds like the Canadian teachers are going a little over the top. Im not a fan of the game, but how can you blame social problems on a game?
06/03/2008
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
Adelaide
BBking
Kudos: 1,028
Mates: 23
Is the topic of this article assumption or censorship?

Censorship: Yeah, I reckon they should sell it. Poeple can play what they want. If a kid bullies someone, then they MIGHT have this game in their bedroom. The kid who got bullied might also. There are bullies out there.

Assumption: Having not played that game I think it would be pretty gay. The facial expressions seem a bit overboard and looks, well, I have to use that word again. Gay.

Are they resposable for destroying gaming? I don't think so...
06/03/2008
Boom Blox
Sydney, NSW. Hills District
trinest
Kudos: 1,930
Mates: 21

ArkiveZero said: game sucks anyway, Rockstar needs to get banned theyre the gay ass ppl that are responsible for destroying gaming



Wat.

Anyway I will get this game ^_^
06/03/2008
Disaster: Day of Crisis
Tamworth, New South Wales, Australia
WiiWillRoc
Kudos: 623
Mates: 19
.................. nothing to say .......
06/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
In my basement playing Brawl! XD
Drhobo
Kudos: 4,364
Mates: 563
Sigh.......Oh canada, when will you learn?
06/03/2008
MyWii - Miscellaneous
Michigan, USA
Diabollus
Kudos: 4,571
Mates: 24

nonsimia47 said: FIGHT COMFORMITY!



What, just because you said so? That would defeat the purpose.


As King Missile once said,

"I want to be different, like all the other different people."
06/03/2008
ArkiveZero
Kudos: 227
Mates: 17
game sucks anyway, Rockstar needs to get banned theyre the gay ass ppl that are responsible for destroying gaming
06/03/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
greenwood, missouri
grimace
Kudos: 2,333
Mates: 58
Hey that's what I thought this game was about too... Oh well, give the teachers a Wii and a copy of the game, then they'll see.
06/03/2008
Zack & Wiki: Quest For Barbaros' Treasure
some random suburb in Perth, WA
nonsimia47
Kudos: 943
Mates: 34
FIGHT COMFORMITY!
06/03/2008
House of the Dead 2 & 3 Return
USA
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyWii Says:

News Action

Polls

Games

  • Anubis II
  • Monster 4x4 World Circuit
  • Open Season
  • Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Double Agent

News

Videos

  • Game Almighty Week In Review Episode 3
    Game Almighty Week In Review Episode 3
  • FIFA 08 Wii Gameplay
    FIFA 08 Wii Gameplay
  • Kid Chameleon REVIEW
    Kid Chameleon REVIEW
  • Wii Bowling 300 (wii sports)
    Wii Bowling 300 (wii sports)

Best Photos

  • The Geekini
    34 30
  • Show us your B00B5!
    47 28
  • Squirrel marine
    9 22
  • LOL!
    35 20
  • The Search for the lost kids.
    21 19
  • Me & Mario
    8 15

Blogs

Comments

Everyone is...

rouronijohn: not too good at brawl but can hold my own in MK wii...although that game is random and i lose a lot of point to blue shells and the like.
Weasle: Hey gonna get NBA 09 On Wii Yay!!!
Guyver: I'm in the same boat dsreaper, at least there's cash in it.
jackoltene: not happy-_-
dsreaper: So pissed off I have to work tomorrow I just want ONE full weekend off :'(