Best Australian Nintendo Wii Community, News, Games, Videos, Competitions, and Forums. Mario Galaxy, Metroid and More!

Wii News \ Harmonix and Neversoft trade blows over Rock Band, Guitar Hero

Guitar Hero director Brian Bright was talking to Eurogamer and this is what he said.

"I don't know how far ahead they planned that - we obviously revealed [our drum kit] much earlier than they did," said Bright, referencing Harmonix' plan to release separate clip-on cymbals for Rock Band set-ups.

"I've a feeling there was a: 'Oh s***! There's cymbals! How can we put cymbals on our kit?' That would be the easiest way without having to rewire everything and re-engineer the entire circuit board."

He also stated that "My understanding on that drum kit is the cymbals are dual-mapped, so it's just another way to trigger the exact same thing you can trigger on the kit."


He is saying he came up with it first but Rock Band released the drums first.


John Drake, Harmonix responded to Bright by saying.

“It might just look like more songs, but really the technology that we’re pushing forward, and some of the features we’ve added, it’s not just a title update: it really is a new game with a lot of really great stuff. We actually have expansion ports on the back of our drum kits that let you attach three cymbals to your drum set. At Harmonix we really are musicians first and game people second… My drum set has three cymbals on it - I don’t know how many drum sets you’ve seen with two cymbals on them; I guess that’s a question for other people.”

So what should we get GH or RB?


jackoltene Kudos: 21327  Mates: 1571
29/08/2008 350 Views 7 Votes
submit to digg

Join MyWii to vote for your favourite story!

Source URL:

http://gonintendo.com/?p=54074

Comments

jackoltene
Kudos: 21,327
Mates: 1571
it looks like GH4 will win
30/08/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
sydney
L-macca
Kudos: 535
Mates: 39

uturn said: get guitar hero, in my opinion rock band is just a cheap rip off, i mean guitar hero had the original idea rock band just went and add 2new musical instroments. dont get me wrong rock band isn't a bad game (though i have played it and didn't like it) its just guitar hero came up with the concept

ur soooo dum rock band 1 came out b4 GH even had the idea about making gh4 a band game but at the moment rockband2 apparently has sum sort of other set where there are symbols but with th game u still get the same sort of drums from rock band 1 except they dont make as much noise
im goin with gh4 bcoz they hav a studio and im experienced recording with frends i might get rock band 2 but thats l8r down the trak
30/08/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Perth
Slick
Kudos: 704
Mates: 32
I'm going both, if Rock Band 2 comes out here, and I can use my GH3 guitar. But I will be getting GH: WT no matter what.
29/08/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
QUEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNSSSSSLLLLLLLLLAAAAAAANNNNNNNDDDDDDERRRRRRR!
CrackM8RX
Kudos: 207
Mates: 5

uturn said: get guitar hero, in my opinion rock band is just a cheap rip off, i mean guitar hero had the original idea rock band just went and add 2new musical instroments. dont get me wrong rock band isn't a bad game (though i have played it and didn't like it) its just guitar hero came up with the concept



Well didn't Konami come up with this same idea in the arcades almost a decade ago? I believe that is why Konami was suing both groups.
29/08/2008
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
Illinois, US
Robtot
Kudos: 8,315
Mates: 142
Well the Rockband guys are former employees of the Guitar Hero gang who bailed when Activision wouldn't go for the 'band' idea correct? I could be wrong on that, but every time I see Rockband vs Guitar Hero I just lol due to the stupid amount of high school drama around the intertwined history
29/08/2008
Wii Fit
...undiluted awesome probably not coming for quite some time, if ever...
uturn
Kudos: 332
Mates: 7
get guitar hero, in my opinion rock band is just a cheap rip off, i mean guitar hero had the original idea rock band just went and add 2new musical instroments. dont get me wrong rock band isn't a bad game (though i have played it and didn't like it) its just guitar hero came up with the concept
29/08/2008
Guitar Hero: Aerosmith
USA
sjt333
Kudos: 15,864
Mates: 147
but those drum rhythm arcade games were the first ones to have cymbals many many years ago
29/08/2008
Altered Beast
Jofra01.9
Kudos: 19,001
Mates: 110

Robtot said: Oh ****, cymbal wars!



Duck Robtot one's flying in from behind
29/08/2008
Captain Rainbow
Don't Be Surprised If I Ain't Here Later
Robtot
Kudos: 8,315
Mates: 142
Oh ****, cymbal wars!
29/08/2008
Wii Fit
...undiluted awesome probably not coming for quite some time, if ever...
jackoltene
Kudos: 21,327
Mates: 1571
Looks pretty interesting, they're fighting over the games ALREADY
29/08/2008
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
sydney
To participate in this discussion, please log in or register.
MyWii Says:

Wii Polls

Wii Games

  • Hot Wheels Beat That
  • CSI: Hard Evidence
  • Earache: Extreme Metal Racing
  • Mario Kart Wii

Wii News

Wii Videos

  • Boogie
    Boogie "Karaoke" Trailer
  • SSBB Final Smash Compilation
    SSBB Final Smash Compilation
  • Mario goes on a killing spree
    Mario goes on a killing spree
  • Vadrum Meets Super Mario Bros (Drum Video)
    Vadrum Meets Super Mario Bros (Drum Video)

Wii Photos

  • PARTY TIME!!!!!!
    24 67
  • O RLY?
    19 25
  • MegaMan
    23 21
  • mudkipz cake
    19 19
  • Build A SNES! =D
    8 17
  • Bunnies Instincts
    5 14

Wii Lists

Peter (narrating his life)
21 9 181 07/09/2008

Robtot's Birthday Song
19 13 165 5 days ago

Dreams, and why i hate them
18 14 170 06/09/2008

What makes thegame10 aroused
14 14 169 10/09/2008

My Best Bad Jokes
14 13 147 07/09/2008

Wii Classifieds

Resident Evil 4
Melbourne $40.00
25 0 2 days ago sasukekun12

NES (not working) + Games
Perth $0.00
66 0 3 days ago jimmiq

SNES + Games
Perth $100.00
67 3 3 days ago jimmiq

GC Games - Mario Party 4, Mario Kart Double Dash & Crash Tag Team Racing
Nambucca Heads, Nsw, Australia, Earth, Solar System, Milky Way Galaxy, Universe $35.00
142 1 07/09/2008 Lucky6ix

Rockman EXE Transmission
Don't Be Surprised If I Ain't Here Later $25.00
125 0 06/09/2008 Jofra01.9

MyWii Blogs

Wii Games Out This Month

Carnival Games: Mini Golf
September 2008 0

FIFA 09 All Play
September 2008 18

Wario Land: Shake It!
22 September 2008 9

Samba de Amigo
25 September 2008 23

We Ski
28 September 2008 13

MyWii Comments

Everyone is...

violetv: tbh it was alright, i think i have too much expectation for this film so it ended up disappointed me little, it was bit anti-climatic but i just couldn't resist wall-e look, his too cute!!
Lucky6ix: Godnight Fellow Wiians
ICC_06: I'm seeing Wall-E on Wednesday, it better be good :p
nyltiak: @violetv - was it good?
violetv: I saw Wall-E....!